| ISSUE | BANK GARNISHMENT | TURNOVER RECEIVERSHIP |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | LONG – 14 days (justice court) or 20-27 days (county/district court), plus time to negotiate agreed judgment with bank | SHORT – Typically 3-4 business days - as little as 2 days if defendant and bank are both responsive |
| Negotiate | NO – Creditor can’t negotiate with defendant until answer filed by bank with claim for bank attorney fees. | YES – receiver can settle with defendant at any time |
| Impact | SEVERE - The defendant is not even a party to the action. Creditor can’t instruct the bank to take any action, even in emergencies | FLEXIBLE - Receiver can negociate with defendant to minimize impact of freeze |
| Costs | HIGH – another filing fee, constable's fee, bank attorney's fee. All taxed to Defendant per statute (not subject to court oversight) | MODERATE - Receivership fees subject to court oversight - no charge to defendant if unsuccessful |
| ISSUE | WRIT OF EXECUTION | TURNOVER RECEIVERSHIP |
| Proceeds | LOW – Assets sold on courthouse steps, lower proceeds if someone bids | MARKET – Receiver can broker the sale to maximize value |
| Flexibility | LOW – deputy/constable cannot set up payment plan longer than life of writ | HIGH – receiver can negotiate with defendant for entire term of judgment |
| Exemptions | SAME - Property Code Chapters 41 & 42 | SAME - Property Code Chapters 41 & 42 |
| Costs | HIGH – Writ issuance fee, Constable service fee, Constable fee percentage of assets sold. All taxed to Defendant per statute (not subject to court oversight) | MODERATE - Receivership fees subject to court oversight - no charge to defendant if unsuccessful |